next up previous
Next: General Analysis Up: Two-sided learning in an Previous: Introduction

Model

A single producer periodically (at discrete times tex2html_wrap_inline1158 ) generates sets of N articles. It sets a subscription fee F and a price schedule tex2html_wrap_inline1164 , where P(k) represents the price it charges for a subset of tex2html_wrap_inline1168 of the N articles.

At a given time t, each of M consumers are informed about tex2html_wrap_inline1176 , and they decide whether to subscribe. Then, each subscribing consumer receives abstracts of all N articles, and uses them to assess its value tex2html_wrap_inline1180 from reading each article, for tex2html_wrap_inline1182 . We assume that these values are generated randomly according to a distribution tex2html_wrap_inline1184 , where tex2html_wrap_inline1186 is the set of parameters that define the distribution for consumer i. The parameters tex2html_wrap_inline1186 that represent consumer i's valuation distribution are themselves generated randomly prior to time 0 from a distribution tex2html_wrap_inline1194 . Once the tex2html_wrap_inline1186 parameters are generated for consumer i, they remain fixed for the rest of time (though the agents may not know their true values for a while, if ever).

After assessing the value of each article, a subscriber decides which articles to purchase. It does this by choosing a set of articles K to maximize surplus tex2html_wrap_inline1202 . Henceforth we assume that the articles have been sorted by consumer j so that the tex2html_wrap_inline1180 are ordered highest to lowest, and thus the set K consists of the first k=|K| articles.

The subscription decision depends on consumer expectations. If a consumer believes correctly that its valuations are drawn from a distribution with parameters tex2html_wrap_inline1186 , then its expected surplus from purchasing k articles would be

  equation56

The consumer can then derive the vector of values tex2html_wrap_inline1216 , the probabilities that any k is the expected surplus maximizing number of articles. Then the consumer's optimized expected surplus is

  equation61

The consumer should subscribe gifif and only if the expectation tex2html_wrap_inline1220 exceeds the subscription fee F.

If consumer i does not know its own tex2html_wrap_inline1186 for the articles offered by this broker, then values tex2html_wrap_inline1228 are the consumer's beliefs drawn from a distribution tex2html_wrap_inline1230 after reviewing the abstracts, where the tex2html_wrap_inline1232 are the agent's current best estimate of the valuation parameters tex2html_wrap_inline1186 . When the agent purchases and reads articles, it learns their true values tex2html_wrap_inline1180 and can then use this sample information to update its beliefs tex2html_wrap_inline1232 about the distribution of article values. Therefore, a good consumer strategy should take into account the value of learning. For example, when uncertainty about tex2html_wrap_inline1186 is high, the consumer might deliberately subscribe even when its estimated surplus is less than F, simply to experience more articles to improve its valuation estimates. Or, having subscribed the consumer might purchase more articles than would maximize expected surplus from current reading.

Turning to the producer's problem, it can choose a subscription fee F and a price schedule tex2html_wrap_inline1246 in each period. These should be chosen to maximize some function of expected current and future profits, where current profit can be expressed as:

  equation80

with tex2html_wrap_inline1248 if consumer i chooses to subscribe, and 0 otherwise. The cost of delivering tex2html_wrap_inline1252 articles to consumer i is denoted as tex2html_wrap_inline1256 .

In performing its maximization, the producer must take into account the effect of tex2html_wrap_inline1246 and F on the consumer's subscription decisions, and the effect of tex2html_wrap_inline1246 on the distribution of tex2html_wrap_inline1252 across the set of subscribers. Higher prices will decrease the number of subscribers and the expected number of articles purchased, of course. To compute the optimal subscription fee and price schedule the broker wants to know the distribution tex2html_wrap_inline1194 from which the consumers' parameters were generated, and the consumer strategies for subscribing and purchasing. Based on its current beliefs about tex2html_wrap_inline1268 and consumer strategies, the broker can simulate a consumer population and its responses to various tex2html_wrap_inline1176 schedules, and then pick tex2html_wrap_inline1176 to maximize a value function. In practice, the broker may not know the consumer type parameters tex2html_wrap_inline1268 , nor the consumer strategies. Thus, the broker may choose tex2html_wrap_inline1176 to balance current expected profit according to equation (3), against the increase in expected future profit from learning about consumer preferences by observing their behavior when confronted with varying tex2html_wrap_inline1176 combinations.


next up previous
Next: General Analysis Up: Two-sided learning in an Previous: Introduction

kephart
Thu Nov 18 11:46:57 EST 1999