Game 1, black
6...c6
Commentary for black move 6:
Mr. ASHLEY: Sorry to interrupt you, Yaz, but Deep Blue has
played another move, c7-c6. A very solid move indeed and this
would want be typically the strategy you would expect a
computer to employ, you would expect much more sharp moves.
Right now it's playing a very solid position. One thing I
heard, though, is that this year they've tweaked it a little
bit and given it more chess knowledge, so to speak, given it a
certain ability to play these types of positions that it really
did not have in the past. How successful do you think it could
be at this, Mike?
Mr. VALVO: I think it could be the critical factor as to how
well Deep Blue does this year. I know from behind-the-scenes
kind of stuff that the whole positional evaluation that they
had before has been improved. And if they are able to solve a
lot of these pinning situations -- they had a problem with pins
last year -- if they could solve those kinds of situations,
they could be a real problem for Garry.
Mr. VALVO: One of the questions that I didn't finish answering
you had asked before, why can't computers play well in blocked
positions. Well, in open positions they have a thing called
move extensions. Which means, if I capture something, I'm not
going to stop analyzing there. I'm going to see what happens.
If he can recapture and I will exhaust all capture situations
down to their end, which is something I'm not going to bother
doing in some blocked positions, not even have the opportunity
of doing.
Mr. VALVO: In tactical situations that could be a big edge to
the computer. Tactical situations in fact are to a computer's
advantage.
Mr. ASHLEY: Right, we saw that in game one last year where
Kasparov --
Mr. SEIRAWAN: Got massacreed.
Mr. ASHLEY: Got crush. He sacrificed a pawn thinking that he
had a great king-side attack but the computer had calculated it
to the finish and admittedly humans would not have taken that
pawn unless you were drunk or something, but in that situation
the computer had worked everything out to Kasparov's being
crushed, instead of itself being mated. And so Garry ended up
losing that game and he learned his lesson well and avoided
sharp, open tactical positions from that moment on.
Mr. VALVO: Can I tell you something from last year's game that
wasn't well known?
Mr. ASHLEY: Please.
Mr. VALVO: Garry left his score sheet behind. That's the only
game he forgot his score sheet. He was tty upset.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: You're talking about the game he lost in game
one?
Mr. VALVO: The game he lost, yeah.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: Probably didn't want to keep it.
Mr. VALVO: If you are familiar with chest collectors, score
sheets are worth about 50 to $100 a score sheet. He asked me
later "What happened to my score sheet?"
Mr. ASHLEY: Well, there are two perspectives on this match.
Some people think it's a total mismatch. On one side you have
Garry Kasparov, world champion, acknowledged being maybe the
best player of all time. Just had a great tournament, Las
Palmas. Massacreed everybody, his rating is now 2820,
something frightful up in the stratosphere, he knows
everything, eats, drinks, talks, sleeps chess, you don't want
to be near the man on a chessboard because you're going to get
killed. And in addition to that, he devastated the computer
last year, 4-2, three wins, after the first game didn't lose
another game, looked very confident. People are saying well,
it's all Garry.
Mr. ASHLEY: On the other side, Deep Blue has improved 200
million positions a second, double what they did last year.
And it played on a keynote it played at least even with Garry
three of those games last year, drew two and won one. Maybe
its chances are not so bad, especially with all the help it's
gotten over the last year. Kasparov has been thinking about
other things other than Deep Blue since last year and all the
Deep Blue team has been thinking about is this match, the
be-all, end-all of their existence to the moment. I do want to say
those about those following over the Internet. Some will
see this visually, some with WebTV will be able to watch all
the action as it's happening now. Some won't, so we'll try to
set everything up for you as Yaz did before. We have three
huge computer screens, one showing the board at all times,
another showing Garry, sometimes the board and sometimes the
operator. Unfortunately we'll never got a chance to see the
Deep Blue screen. We do have a clock, this is a new clock that
Garry Kasparov has instituted and it shows the time, what's
going on. Right now Kasparov has used 12 minutes and Deep
Blue
has used eight minutes. So it's a little bit ahead on the
clock. On the second screen we do have Fritz four where we'll
do all our analysis. Right now --
Mr. ASHLEY: Not too much happening, because pawns are not
touching.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: Yes.
Mr. ASHLEY: What should be the plan here?
Mr. SEIRAWAN: We see Garry as kind of -- he seems to have his
head in the sky a bit there, what he would like to do.
Essentially what people miss about chess, as far as the opening
is concerned, the entire purpose of the opening is to get a
/PHRAEUBL middle game that is to say, "Hey, the kind of
position" that the player would like to play. And then as it
kind of dovetails into the middle game, the idea is what will
be my overall strategy.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: So Garry is not looking seriously, he is not
looking at one or two moves in distance acquisition. What he's
thinking is what I want to do overall with my pieces. Now,,
the essence of the question that he has to ask himself is, how
do I control the board? What is happening? And in chess, in
great battles, like in warfare, is to control the center of the
board. And by the center of the board I mean specifically the
squares from c4, d4, e4, all the way from e4, e5, e6, back to
e6, d6, c6, and back through c5 and c4. This area here is the
center of the board. So what Garry could consider doing is
bringing the c-pawn to the c4 square, bringing the d-pawn to
the d4 square to control e5, or trying to advance his E pawn
later in the game. The point is, what Deep Blue has set its
defenses around is the key square, the d5 square and the d5
pawn. Very powerfully supported by the c6 pawn and the e6
pawn. So what Garry has to say to himself is "How am I going
to make a dent in Deep Blue's position?" And again, he's not
looking at one or two moves.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: He's saying, "Overall, what will my key strategy
be?" And quite frankly, he has I would say three key
strategies. The first key strategy is to play the move c2-c4
followed by Nc3 and try to play on the left flank, or the
queen-side flank. A second strategy would be to try to play
d2-d4, bring the night on b1 to e2 and follow up with Nf3-e5.
Playing on the dark squares.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: And the third strategy is to play the move d3
followed by Nb1-d2 and then e2-e4.
Mr. ASHLEY: We should note that the watch is off! (Laughter.)
And that means another 20 minutes, probably.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: I must say that I have played Garry countless
blitz games. That is to say, "fun" games. They weren't that
much fun, but we played a lot. (Laughter.) And we have played
together seven tournament games, including a game played in the
Olympics. My score with Garry is two draws, one victory for me
(pumping fist) -- yea! Now the bad news. Three victories for him.
And during this many hours of playing with Garry, and
also not just playing against him directly, but also being in
competitions with him, he reveals himself.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: Garry is very much an open person, and he
wears
his emotions openly. When he doesn't like his position, he's
shaking his head, and he's gnashing of the teeth and grrrr --
growling. And when he's winning, he's beaming.
Mr. ASHLEY: Surprise, surprise, the move has come quickly. He's
played the move d2-d3, and instantly Deep Blue has responded
with Bd6. Now, this means one of two things --
Mr. VALVO: This means one of two things.
Mr. ASHLEY: Kasparov has continued the bravado and played
Nb1-d2. And the action came tty quick there with Deep Blue
still continuing as if saying "I dare you to top this," he's
castling.
Mr. ASHLEY: And Kasparov is instantly responding h2-h3, so a
flurry of moves --
Mr. ASHLEY: And Deep Blue has answered, blitz chess, speed
chess
right now. Bg2-h5, and we'll recap these moves when we get a
break. (Laughter.) Finally, it's Kasparov who has stopped to
think about the position. All that happened in about a minute.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: Well, I was explaining to Garry that the Seattle
Supersonics are playing game five. If he wanted to watch the
fourth quarter. So, yes, they just really blitzed out those
moves.
Mr. ASHLEY: That was amazing. Why don't we go back a few
moves
to where this all started, since Kasparov is thinking about his
position. It all started right here where he played d2-d3,
following the strategy you said he should initiate.
Mr. SEIRAWAN: Yes. This is actually the third choice. I
personally would not have made the choice that Garry did --
Real-time text commentary is made possible by LiveNote, Inc.
and Vincent Varallo
Associates